Facebook has always claimed that only data are collected from users who have opted, but in a tranche of internal emails, retrieved as part of a lawsuit against the company and by the Committee on Digital Media, Culture, Media and sports are discussed, employees discuss how they can reduce the required consent to a minimum beginning of the collection.
"The growth team is planning to ship an approval update for Android later this month," wrote Michael LeBeau, then the company's project manager, in an email sent in February 201
"You will have the Read Call Log permission" ion … for a feature that allows you to continuously upload your SMS and call log data to Facebook, "he continued. "This is a fairly risky exercise from a PR perspective, but it seems that the growth team will pre-calculate and do that … We believe that the risk of a PR default is high.
"Screenshot of the frightening Android permissions screen becomes a meme, spreads on the web, gains the attention of the press, and enterprising journalists look for what the new update specifically demands, and then write reports about" Facebook uses the new one Android update to immerse yourself in your private life in ever more frightening ways – Read your call logs and track them in companies with beacons, etc. "
Yul Kwon, one of the company's" privacy surgeons, "whose job it was "To make sure that Facebook does not trigger any data protection dynamism," LeBeau responded with an alternative plan: "The growth team is now exploring a path where we can only request permission to read call logs and request more permissions for the time being.
"This seems to be the case based on their initial testing on Let's update the users without passing them on to an Android permissions dialog box It would still be a groundbreaking change, so users would have to click to refresh it will not display any permissions dialog box. "
Due to the changes, Facebook, as Facebook began to ask permission in the app, could write its own request instead of using the default language of Google's Android operating system.
In it Query did not mention any call logs, users were asked if they would like to "send and receive text messages in messenger" in a request box without a "no" button, instead the two options had a blue button labeled "OK "or a grayed-out link to" Settings. "
Since many users already use the technic when installing the app If Facebook had the app installed, they were confirmed with OK. It was the last thing they knew about call and text logging – until they rediscovered the logs in March this year.
In a statement released Wednesday, Facebook said, "The feature is enabled for users and we ask for permission from people before activation. We are always the best way to ask for permission from a person, be it through a permission dialog established by a mobile operating system such as Android or iOS, or through a permission that we design in the Facebook app.
"With this feature we asked permission was saved in the Facebook Messenger app. This was a discussion of how our decision to launch this opt-in feature would interact with the authorization screens of the Android operating system. This was not a discussion about avoiding people being asked for permission. "